How to Tell if Your Water Tank is Oversized?

Quick-answer: If your stored water isn’t turning over within 24 hours, the tank is likely oversized and at risk of stagnation. Tell-tale signs include visible surface contamination such as scum, biofilm or floating debris, slimy deposits on internal surfaces, discolouration, odour, or repeated microbiological failures. A correctly sized tank should support regular turnover within 24 hours and maintain clean, clear water with no microbiological fouling.

Why tank size matters for your facility water system

Meeting demand without excess

In any commercial or industrial building, the storage tank plays a central role in your water supply strategy - whether that’s potable water, cold-water storage or fire-reserve duty. The tank must be sized to cater for peaks, maintenance interruptions and demand fluctuations, yet should not be so large that water becomes static for extended periods. For example, Drinking Water Inspectorate guidance emphasises: “the tank or reservoir should hold a volume sufficient to accommodate the peak demand and the maximum period of interruption of supply, but must not be so large that water is allowed to remain static for lengthy periods”.

Cost, space and efficiency implications

An oversized water storage tank often brings hidden inefficiencies: increased capital cost (tank shell, support structure, insulation), larger footprint or plant-room space, greater energy to maintain water temperature, more complex circulation arrangements. Recent commentary notes that in modern buildings, “rightsizing pumps and storage tanks … maximises efficiency, reduces waste and optimises available space”.

Hygiene and water-quality risk

From a hygiene perspective, a volume of water that seldom turns over increases water age, which leads to stagnation, layering (thermal stratification), sediment build-up and potential microbial growth. Technical guidance highlights that retention time is critical: “the retention time of treated water storage tanks can have a significant impact on water quality”.

Key indicators your water tank may be oversized

Low draw-off or long residence time

If your tank’s volume is rarely drawn down - say only a small percentage is used between fills - then the turnover rate is poor. Long residence time means the water remains in the tank too long (>24 hours), increasing the risk of chemical change or bacterial growth. This is a strong sign the tank capacity is greater than its duty.

Frequent cleaning or maintenance burden without benefit

If cleaning, disinfection or flushing schedules are driven by the sheer volume of stored water (rather than actual usage), you may be carrying an oversized tank. For example, guidance for cold-water storage notes that excessive capacity “can cause water to stagnate, increasing the risk of harmful bacteria”.

Excessive footprint, structural cost or inefficient hydraulics

Oversized tanks may cause flow issues: dead zones, partial mixing, stratification or long circuit travel times. If your plant-room has been sized more for tank volume than for practical duty, or you find structural reinforcements (floors, roofs) were driven by capacity rather than functional need, these are red flags. The industry advice is clear: correct design avoids over-specification of storage.

How to assess and right-size your tank

Calculate actual usage and reserve requirement

Start with actual operating data. Record water draw-off volumes, peak demand periods, contingency needs (fire suppression, maintenance down-time). Use this to determine the required storage capacity rather than relying on generic “big-just-in-case” margins.

Compare installed capacity with turnover rate

Drain/interrogate the tank: how much is used between fills; how frequently does the volume fully cycle? If you observe only a small fraction of the water is drawn before refill, your tank is likely oversized. Also examine how long the water sits in the tank - if the age of the water exceeds 24 hours, performance may suffer.

Review circulation, inlet-outlet placement and system design

Even a tank with correct litre-capacity may behave as if oversized if the internal flow arrangements are poor: dead zones, stratification and sediment build-up emerge when mixing is inadequate. Design guidance emphasises inlet/outlet positioning.

Decide on mitigation or replacement

If your assessment confirms the tank is oversized: consider options such as partitioning the tank, reducing effective volume, improving circulation, or replacing the tank with a right-sized unit. Always maintain a balance between duty, future growth, risk (e.g., legionella, fire-reserve) and cost-benefit.

Practical tips for facilities managers

• Ensure your water-system risk assessment (including for ACoP L8 and legionella control) addresses tank size, turnover rate, residence time, and water age.

• Keep usage records - volume draw-off, peak times, refill frequency - looking for trends that show storage excess.

• Review the tank at least annually: inspect actual water turn-over, check for dead zones, stratification, sediment or poor circulation, and compare to design assumptions.

• If tank appears oversized, focus on mitigation: improving circulation, adding mixers, installing automatic flush sequences, fitting level sensors to trigger draw-down.

• Document your decision-making: If you retain a large tank, record the reasoning (future expansion, contingency, fire duty) and the controls in place to manage risk.

• For more on hygiene, inspection and maintenance of storage tanks see our cold water storage tanks services page.

Conclusion

An oversized water storage tank may initially appear conservative or safe - but for a facilities manager, it often represents hidden inefficiencies and increasing risk. The correct capacity aligns with actual draw-off, ensures sufficient turnover, avoids stagnation, minimises energy and space cost, and supports good water hygiene.

By recording usage data, assessing residence time and reviewing system flow, you can determine whether your tank is truly fit for purpose. If not, you have options to optimise or replace.

Learn More